The Citizens Committee, a group of minorities in Louisiana, chose Homer Plessy to challenge a state law requiring segregation on trains.
After Plessy was arrested for boarding a whites-only train car and found guilty of breaking the law, the Citizens Committee appealed his conviction. Ferguson (Ferguson refers to Judge John Howard Ferguson, who presided over the case in Louisiana) ended up at the Supreme Court.
The underlying reason for a separate railway car is obviously a belief by the Louisiana legislature that African Americans are an inferior race.
The Louisiana law and the majority misinterpret the civil rights protected in our color-blind constitution. Ferguson continued to permit public segregation under the guise of “separate but equal.” It ultimately set back civil rights in the United States and resulted in many businesses defining themselves as “serving whites only.” Plessy v.
Distinguishing a separate railway car based on race does not imply the inferiority of one race to another because each railway car is “separate but equal.” Dissent (Harlan): The state law should have been invalidated.
Plessy Vs Ferguson Essay Ishmael Daniel Quinn Essays
Governmental bodies should not take into consideration the race of citizens when making legislative civil rights decisions regarding those citizens.
They cited examples of successful black individuals as proof that segregation didn’t necessarily deprive black students of the ability to succeed as adults.
After first failing to reach a decision and ordering both sides to prepare more information on the relationship between the 14th Amendment and education, the Supreme Court rehears the case. [It] is a right which must be made available to all on equal terms.” In contrast to Plessy v.
This week marks the anniversaries of two landmark Supreme Court cases dealing with segregation. Ferguson, upheld the constitutionality of segregation under the “separate but equal” doctrine.
The other high court ruling, nearly six decades later, found that “separate educational facilities are inherently unequal.” An 1892 incident triggered the Plessy lawsuit.